I decided to write this post because it always annoys me to hear people telling you that ‘you have to forgive your parents’ and that if you haven’t done that and you are dwelling on whatever transgressions they committed against you in your childhood, you are somehow wrong.
People who dispense such advise have a misguided idea that if only you forgive and let go and focus on the future, you would be able to lead a perfectly happy life as if the bad stuff never happened.
I really want to make a very clear point here that this is not true.
I am not talking about some petty grievances in families that otherwise function well, where parents fulfil their parental roles and provide stability, love and nurturing to the children. I am talking about families with pervasive dysfunction, about parents with various degrees of personality disorders and other mental illnesses, where there is continuous neglect, emotional invalidation, unpredictability and abuse of any kind and that includes psychological and emotional abuse (a lot of abused children are stuck in the ‘I deserved it’ mindset, essentially a Stockholm Syndrom situation, into which they were thrown by their parents. The worst abusers are either not aware or not willing to admit that their behaviour is abusive and have to rationalise it for themselves. Hence the blame the victim mentality that the child victim very easily absorbs).
For a child born into such an environment, there is no healthy before. There is no healthy reference point before the trauma happened where you could return to and start rebuilding your life from. It has been sufficiently backed by science now that people who have experienced a higher number of adverse childhood experiences (ACE) are considerably more likely to struggle in life, suffer from mental health problems and have a way higher likelihood of developing all sorts of diseases including cardiovascular diseases and cancer. The nervous system of such people is wired all differently. It’s wired for a constant fight or flight, it tends to be in a constant survival mode, it is wired to expect put-downs, attacks, betrayals. That’s how the person has been trained since their first breaths and that’s how he or she relates to the world. On the genetic level, complex childhood trauma shortens telomeres and affects the epigenome. These are some really bad cards to be dealt without your own choosing.
So let’s have a look at my life. I was born a very energetic, vivacious and capable child. I was able to walk at eight months old, I remember riding a bicycle at three without side wheels, school was easy, everything went straight into my brain. I remember that I didn’t have to put much effort in and I was actually super motivated. On weekend mornings, when my parents would be sleeping out their last night’s party, I would take a book and read aloud to myself. Soon, I was best at reading in my class.
However, by the age of 12, I started unravelling. First, came the eating disorder and self-hatred, then came suicidal ideation and self-harming. Throughout high school I still had that amazingly functioning brain that could take in and figure out just about anything. But it wasn’t to last.
At 21 I had a big breakdown that I had to pull through totally by myself and shortly after developed severe insomnia that has plagued my life ever since. Whilst my peers were enjoying their carefree twenties, I was popping sleeping pills and doing a lot of yoga and relaxation to make up for all the lost sleep and anxiety. I still did quite well and finished both of my degrees but it was becoming more difficult. When I started my first job, I remember frequently plodding through days after sleepless nights with a terrible amount of brain fog. I was scared people would see that I couldn’t perform and extremely stressed by the whole situation. I was self-conscious, struggled to cope with criticism of any kind and constantly thought someone was after me.
I pulled through my twenties, stopped drinking and smoking, which I had started in my teens.
By my early 30s, my body started to show signs of accumulated stress. My hair loss got worse, I got diagnosed with a gynaecological condition. The sleep got somewhat better but still, there were periods when I could hardly sleep for weeks and struggled through the days. A lot of my memories are marred by the cloud of brain fog after a sleepless night. Enjoying work was difficult because I frequently had to push through the days. Enjoying life was difficult too.
There were good periods too, such is the nature of the complex post traumatic stress disorder. It’s a constant up and down, but the downs do eat out quite a lot of your life, they steal the enjoyment. And sometimes you get to some really dark places with full blown panic attacks, self-harming and anxiety.
Then came the narcissist. Another near breakdown and almost two years figuring out what the hell had happened. Today I know that I got enmeshed with someone who was pretty much a vicious combination of both of my parents. I didn’t see it coming despite all the red flags, that much did I consider toxic my normal.
I lead probably the cleanest life one can think of, with meditation, the healthiest food I can find and lots of other healthy habits. Yet, even after five years of intense self-work and four years in therapy, I still struggle with periods of heavy triggering that leaves me in extremely unpleasant states sometimes for weeks. I have processed a lot of my childhood trauma and have grown tremendously from it. Sometimes, I think I have done it all. I have periods of great productivity and enjoyment. And then another thing comes up that sends my brain into a state that I can do nothing with, just wait for it to subside. It’s not happening just in my brain. My entire body feels ill during these periods. It’s impossible to focus on anything, no self-help hacks work.
I often wonder how much better I would have fared in life if this trauma has never happened. If I had just slightly more normal parents. Everything would have been different. I would be different. Sometimes I am angry. I lost the best decades of my life under this post-traumatic stress cloud. I used to blame myself for it, just as I was trained to do in my childhood.
Despite my healthy habits, I still struggle with health issues from hair loss to IBS to endometriosis. Insomnia, is still a regular visitor and so is anxiety and panic attacks.
I have done everything since I became an adult to get better. I have done nothing to deserve it. Yet I get frequently blamed by the uneducated members of the public when I express my upset about the ordeal and my family history. As if I had no right to speak the truth about my life.
I would like to urge anyone who has a need to patronise people who speak about the damage caused by their parents to think again, educate yourself and think what you could do so that no more children turn into CPTSD-riddled adults. It’s not just CPTSD, mental health conditions such as borderline personality disorder are a a result of child abuse and neglect too. Sometimes, an abused and neglected child turns into an avenger that punishes the entire society for what happened to them. The story of Andres Breivik is one such terrifying example.
I am on the path to forgive my parents. I understand that they had and still have some serious mental limitations that prevented them from developing proper parenting (and human) skills and relationships to their children. But it’s hard to cope with the fact that no one ever intervened while very many people knew I was struggling as a child. It seems to me that using this experience and turning it into something that can perhaps help others is the only possible way to find any purpose in it.
I had a great childhood… however I too was in a relationship with a narcissist that lasted far too long and the effects still damage me, years later.
I don’t know if forgiving those who caused you pain is the answer. I ponder that a lot too. Often, forgiving someone else is for our own healing, not theirs….
Painful lessons learned after many years takes A LOT to forgive. I think if you knew your mother and father could feel genuine regret/remorse it would help… however if they are still toxic I don’t see the point in forgiving them. Sometimes we move on in our own ways, forgiveness isn’t always a necessary component. ❤️
Just my thoughts, some may disagree, that’s okay.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Of course, it’s for you and not them. They don’t even say they are sorry, they don’t even say they fucked up, which would make the forgiving way easier. They say you made it up, essentially abusing you further. At the end you accept that they are mentally ill and let go of the anger. That was my biggest issue. The visceral hatred to them, which I thought was toxic to me. But it was me clinging to the idea that they are normal, like me and that there can be a genuine relationship, a genuine apology, remorse and some sort of repair of the relationship… that was a wrong assumption…
LikeLike
Absolutely. We cling to the idea that they can be normal or have some shred of decency… I so understand
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for sharing this. Invalidating people’s pain never helps and makes things much worse. I don’t believe in forgiveness. I believe more in acceptance of self. Learning to feel safe again and be with nurturing people who help you heal and you learn to love yourself. Because you were only taught to hate yourself when you have been traumatized.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for your comment. You are very right in everything you say. At some point the hate towards you that they taught you turns into hate towards them when you realise what they did to you. At some point, however, you need to let go of that hate somehow because it really feels quite unhealthy. So that for me equals forgiveness. You understand their severe limitations as humans and forgive, which obviously doesn’t mean allowing the abuse and invalidation back into your life….
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m a therapist so I get everything you are saying. Your blog is the only one I make time to read. I appreciate your bravery and honesty.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, in this case I am really honoured…
LikeLike
It took me a long time to honor that I have aspects of PTSD from childhood situations. I could totally relate to what you have said here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much for sharing what happened to you and how you have navigated life. I share so many of the same experiences with you. It’s exhausting more than anything at the moment and the lack of understanding of others who believe that family/parents are beyond reproach is a consistent obstacle for me. But I’m getting there. I read somewhere about a woman who said how she had gone through life attached to her toxic family, perpetually scapegoated and all that that entails without understanding what had happened to her. And then after a series of family melt downs it all unravelled. She described it as ‘waking up in her own life’,, or words to that effect, except to her horror she had woken up at the age of 62 and the best years of her life were lost to the toxic behaviour of others. This constantly motivates me to keep moving forwards and give myself the best chance I can for something better in the years ahead. Reading the words of others who know and understand is a huge part of that, so thank you once again for putting into such honest and well-crafted posts what it is we are going through.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey, thank you for your comment. And I’m really sorry that you have to go through this. Not sure where you are based but might be worth looking into the fellowship Adult Children of Alcoholics and Dysfunctional Families to get some extra support. Take care and I wish you the best on your journey…
LikeLike
Thank you so much for this, and for your other similar blog posts. I so relate to so much of what you say, particularly the way you describe how society minimises the experiences of those who’ve gone through the trauma of family scapegoating. It is terrible enough to come to terms with one’s family experience, but then on top of that to have people around you raise their eyebrows and subtly (or not so subtly) imply that you are imagining it… That has happened to me A LOT including with therapists, including group therapy, including with alternative health practitioners. I have come to the conclusion that people who have not themselves personally experienced this level of toxicity simply cannot understand, no matter how well intentioned they are.
I am 51 years old now, and would say it is only within the last year that I have finally begun to accept that it’s “not me, it’s them.” It feels like that new attitude in me has finally begun to stabilise, whereas it see-sawed for many years.
My mother was basically the ringleader in scapegoating me, and she died in 2020. What has been harrowing to me is observing that my sibling is happily continuing the habit of spreading rumours and gossip about me to wider members of the family – my cousins, my nephews, other family members on the periphery.
So – it doesn’t end with the ringleader’s death.
Where I’m at with it now is that sometimes I feel a sense of triumph in having finally really recognised that it is NOT ME. I feel that I am seeing my family members clearly for the first time in my life, and that in itself is helping me to give up any illusions about ever being loved by them.
What I still struggle with is the reality of navigating my way through life without effectively having any family to support me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey, I’m glad if my story helped, and a big hug to you. It sucks terribly what had happened to us. And the invalidation and secondary abuse that we receive from society is appalling. I hope that awareness will increase and at some point it will no longer be acceptable to trash a child abuse survivor. It does suck to go through life without a family support. But as my therapist once told me ‘you were always alone’. So any idea of a family is an illusion with these people anyway, because they show no concern about your well-being at all or any kind of interest. You can only be with them if you completely suppress your truth and deny your experience. You need to build yourself a family of people who are capable of understanding these things, and those are a rare kind. It’s hard, but there is a momentum and things are being discussed more openly.
LikeLike